To change or not to change

Translate

by Eddie Carpenter

Humboldt State University is now Cal Poly Humboldt, and with this shift comes a lot of rebranding. Cal Poly Humboldt’s marketing partner SimpsonScarborough recently sent out a survey regarding possible logo concepts. If the marketing and rebranding is at the heart of this process, I think that we are in a dire need of new mascot. After all, what does a lumberjack really represent?

At first glance, it’s a kind of nod to how pervasive the culture of the timber industry used to be in Humboldt County. At one point in time, it dominated the local job market.

My father was among the masses who used to log up in the hills and work the mill yards. Nowadays, the industry’s number of workers has been reduced to a fraction of what it used to be. Therefore, this figure has sort of faded to the background of the public imagination.

When my friend used to go to the campus bookstore, she was always greeted by a lumberjack cutout that you could put your face in. This is where you too could’ve been a large bearded white man wielding an ax.

Even in advertising, lumberjacks are portrayed asserting their dominance over nature with brute force.

When I look at our mascot, I am reminded of the horrors committed by American settlers in Northern California. In my Native American Studies class, I learned about a book called Genocide in Northwestern California by Jack Norton. In the 1850s, white settlers saw the forests and valley floors as barriers to Manifest Destiny.

There are pictures that depict how the invaders swaggered around mutilated tree trunks. In their final judgment, the white settlers had set fire to the entire forest in order to make sure that the redwoods were vanquished. In turn, Indigenous populations saw their homelands turn to ruins.

I do not think an icon with such a checkered past is very representative of the social equity and diversity that our departments wish to strive for. It is the manifestation of white, cisgendered, heterosexual and patriarchal values.

The question still remains: what should our new mascot be, if not Lucky the Lumberjack? I think that we should consider rebranding ourselves as the Cal Poly Humboldt Bigfoots.

If a tree falls down in the forest and nobody is around to hear it— it must be Bigfoot! He is an anomaly that simply cannot be contained. He thrives by hiding in the foliage and greenery of his environment. Bigfoot could come to represent our local community’s stewardship of the environment.

Whether you’re a skeptic or believer (or perhaps somewhere in between), you cannot deny the impact that the mighty Sasquatch has left around the world. Graduating as Cal Poly Humboldt Bigfoots could mean leaving nothing but footprints in our wake instead of taking from others.

Share This Post

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on email
Share on reddit

More Stories

6 Comments

  1. Michael Robert Sagehorn Michael Robert Sagehorn Wednesday, March 2, 2022

    I’m a Lumberjack. No a Foot.

  2. Alannah Guevara Alannah Guevara Thursday, March 3, 2022

    I love this proposal. Out with the old and in with the new! As a school and a community, it is imperative that we embrace change if that change is for the better. Replacing our worn out mascot with one that’s more inclusive, and, frankly, more exciting can be a small but powerful gesture of comradery between all of our peers, faculty, and other members of the Cal Poly Humboldt community. Besides, human mascots are so outdated, Indigenous, white, or otherwise. Can we start a petition?

  3. James Mathis James Mathis Sunday, March 6, 2022

    What a stupid article. This county was built by logging and the home in which the author of the article lives is made from wood. His last name is Carpenter! Are we worried about offending the woke mob who is against cutting trees while at the same time being pro toilet paper? This article reeks worse than Bigfoot.

  4. Lyn Barnett Lyn Barnett Friday, March 11, 2022

    Wow. With all of the problems facing our country, rebranding Humboldt ranks dead last. This is an expensive waste of scarce resources. CalPoly Humboldt must be doing pretty well financially if they can toss around money on such trivialities. How about redirecting these funds to something meaningful like living wages for employees – or reduced tuition for students? (Class of 1984)

    • Deborah Deborah Thursday, March 31, 2022

      I personally know a former Mascot from
      The late 1960’s! He’s my husband who brought many
      smiles and happiness to all who encountered him!!
      What an insult you are proposing and we totally agree with some of your other readers that this is a “stupid stupid idea to abolish an iconic lumberjack. It makes us wonder if the person writing this article has a life. There are many more important things in this world to think about! Be proud of where you come from and the legacy Lucky Logger carries every time he puts the head on. It is not an easy job and the ones who put Lucky’s head on are a dedicated group of people who care and give to others in what is called “community service.”
      (Two people from the Class of 1966) still alive and well!

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: